Build ID: 117281b-4eb4f62-260b7c1 Working with an older document [1], started 2007, with some grapics and objects in it. These appear on the wrong place in 35Master [3] compared to LO343. When I create a new document in LibO343 with some graphics [4], the problem is not there. When opening another old document [5], with many graphics, it does show problems with placement. It takes many times PgUp, PgDown vice versa to get pictures in place. When I open a guide from ODFAuthors, eg. http://www.odfauthors.org/openoffice.org/english/userguide3/writer3/V3_3_revisions/wg3.3-writer-guide-full-book-odt-10-jan-2011/view and scroll through it, there are some pictures not shown but I see hardly problems with positioning. Notice that all graphics are inserted 'As character' in this guide. I'll make some attachments: 1 - bug document 2 - picture with screenshots of positioning in LibO343 3 - picture with screenshots of positioning in Lib35Master 4 - simple test document from LibO343 5) - I cannot attach this document
Created attachment 50530 [details] 1 - bug document
Created attachment 50531 [details] 2 - picture with screenshots of positioning in LibO343
Created attachment 50532 [details] 3 - picture with screenshots of positioning in Lib35Master
Created attachment 50533 [details] 4 - simple test document from LibO343
Interesting some text paragraphs empty paragraph graphic anchored here at paragraph empty paragraph some text paragraphs When adding text in the first paragraph, so that new lines appear, it takes some time before the graphic is moved down.
Another interesting behaviour a number of text, also some headings, and empty paragraphs some room at the bottom of the page paste a graphic that is too large for the remaining space > graphic and a whole lot of paragraphs are forced to the next page
do we have any idea, e.g. older master builds from the dailies, when this might have come unstuck ? The dream scenario is that we can state that build-id X from a few days ago works, while current build-id Y fails and its a trivial matter of bisecting the changes. We may be too close to the start of available dailies for this to be possible for this bug though.
That sounds as our ideal world :-) maybe I am able to try some older build (local, nightly) in the weekend. (but what the * is going on with the amil that I should recieve from this service :-( )
.
'oldest' masterbuidl I could find was from 2011-08-19 shows the same problems. Any chance to dive up older deb_32 master builds somewhere?
. (test)
. (sorry, test again)
http://dev-builds.libreoffice.org/daily/Fedora_15_gcc-4.6_x86_64_dbgutil/master/2011-08-12_07.17.56/ looks right http://dev-builds.libreoffice.org/daily/Fedora_15_gcc-4.6_x86_64_dbgutil/master/2011-08-24_22.21.51/ looks wrong so I should in theory be able to find the change eventually
somewhere between acd3134..aea70b2
http://cgit.freedesktop.org/libreoffice/core/commit/?id=6f7bd90edcb68a67b63094eae6dae6f144edd5cc is the commit which breaks this. A bit of a success story I reckon, help about gives the git ids, dailies provide a cache of pre-built install sets for bisecting the change.
Created attachment 50565 [details] does this make sense, don't mistake this for "I know what I'm doing"
comment #16 is a stupid patch. Original commit's purpose is to try and not have drawing dropping on editing a footer when appending new paragraphs
[ bugs.freedesktop does send me mail again and see your comments while traveling ...] found a -maybe- related issue yesterday in LibO343. Can provide case this evening. So -maybe- it makes sense to look at that too .. just a few hours, pls ;-)
don't mangle this into a multi-bug catch-all
[ next station ] No fo course not ;-) Tried to reproduce what happened again and again last evening (indeed with images close to/crossing the bottom of a page) Cannot just reproduce it now ;-\ (Older documents ? Will have to pin it down immediately a next time) so pls don't wait for another issue now, AFAIAC. Sorry for the noise.
given: http://cgit.freedesktop.org/libreoffice/core/commit/?id=ca2568e30a5a9154dc17bdc2efed4e2cf3027885 can we close this now then ?
could be related to Bug 33862 - FORMATTING - Some graphics are flipped vertically when opening prior OO documents ?
Just checked in 350rc1 and it works fine there now (also 3.4.5 is OK)