Bug 104955

Created attachment 137174 [details]
udev information for the device

Created attachment 137175 [details]
Wrong tap (record 1)

Created attachment 137176 [details]
Wrong tap (record 2)

Created attachment 137177 [details]
Wrong tap (record 3)

Created attachment 137178 [details]
Correct Swipe (record 4)

== Attached evemu-record ==

I have attached 4 evemu-record logs ( all 3 finger up swipes ):
- first 3 logs/swipe contains the wrong tap ( I just swiped up once and suddenly got a tap )
- last log/swipe didn't create any tap event

let me know if I can add any other information in order to help you to debug the issue



== System Information ==
My PC is a Xiaomi "Mi Book Air 13" ( touchpad physical size 110x65mm ) 
$ dmidecode | grep -A3 '^System Information'
  Manufacturer: Timi
  Product Name: TM1613
  Version: A05

Please test with a recent version of libinput, 1.7.0 is almost a year old which is quite significant given how many changes libinput sees atm. We're close to having a 1.10 release but 1.9.4 is the latest stable release. 

I replayed both tap recordings here and they both give me a swipe gestures, so maybe this has been fixed?

Sorry my fault, I reported the wrong libinput version, 1.7.0 is actually the `libinput-list-devices` version ...

The actual libinput version I am using is:

$ libinput --version
1.9.902

So the issue is still present on last version.

How can I replay the recording ?

weird, libinput-list-devices shouldn't be installed anymore if you upgraded normally, the libinput tool replaced it.

You can replay the recording using sudo  evemu-play <filename>, then hit enter to start the events. Run that after starting sudo libinput debug-events --enable-tap and it should show either the tap or the swipe events, whichever is detected.

I also recommend using the touchad-edge-detector tool first to check if the axis ranges are correct.

ping?

Hi,.
Sorry for late replay I have been a bit busy with work.

I am now using libinput ver: 1.10.900

Regarding libinput-list-devices:
I am not sure why I still have it maybe it is because I am using this AUR to install last libinput version: https://aur.archlinux.org/packages/libinput-git/

Regarding the issue:
I have played attachment 1 [details] [review] and 2 on my computer and I can see I have the application menu popup ( corresponding to 3 finger tap ) on both of them when I play the first input command.

Also I am not sure if it is related, I noted that sometime I try to do a 3 tap but I got a 2 tap ( this is very annoying because 2 finger tap paste text and while I am coding is not a nice thing to get random stuff pasted here and there )

So I think the issue is still present in the last version of libinput ...

Regarding touchpad-edge-detector:
I'll check and report something next week

Hi,.
Sorry for late replay I have been a bit busy with work.

I am now using libinput ver: 1.10.900

Regarding libinput-list-devices:
I am not sure why I still have it maybe it is because I am using this AUR to install last libinput version: https://aur.archlinux.org/packages/libinput-git/

Regarding the issue:
I have played attachment 1 [details] [review] and 2 on my computer and I can see I have the application menu popup ( corresponding to 3 finger tap ) on both of them when I play the first input command.

Also I am not sure if it is related, I noted that sometime I try to do a 3 tap but I got a 2 tap ( this is very annoying because 2 finger tap paste text and while I am coding is not a nice thing to get random stuff pasted here and there )

So I think the issue is still present in the last version of libinput ...

Regarding touchpad-edge-detector:
I'll check and report something next week