Bug 37697

The names of the buttons object alignment, causing the same action, differ in toolbars 'Frame' \ 'OLE-object' and the toolbar 'Align'. Names, same as well as names of the toolbar 'Align' should be used.

[Reproducible] with "LibreOffice 3.4.0RC2  – WIN7  Home Premium  (64bit) English UI [OOO340m1 (Build:12)]" and TANGO theme. The current icons are misleading. In attached sample WRITER document you can use both possibilities for vertical alignment, the floating Align toolbar and the docked Frame toolbar.

The moving of the frame using the buttons in Align toolbar is predictable, you see a reference line and the position of an object relative to the reference line. 

For me the moving of the frame using the buttons in Frame toolbar is unexpected. I press the right button showing an object more nearby bottom of the page, and the frame moves up, that's without logic.

Currently I see this as a WRITER UI problem

@ape:
Can you please try to find out details concerning your OS, PC, LibO version for your reports (although if you expect that the problem is independent)   ;-)

Did you also see this problems for CALC, DRAW, Presentation?

@Michael:
I saw you active in ant least one similar bug report (Bug 36662)
Please feel free to reassign if it's not your area!

Created attachment 47263 [details]
Sample Document, see Comment 2

OS - Windows_XP_64bit_ENU+MUI_RU,LibO-3.4.0rc2. But this error appears in the Linux OS (Ubuntu-10.04_LiveCD). This same error found in the OpenOffice.org-2.4.2.

@Rainer Bielefeld
Description concerns to Writer.
Draw, Impress - access to objective alignment is carried out through the button 'Alignment' (Drawing_Object_Properties toolbar); toolbars 'OLE-object' and 'Frame' available in the View menu.
Calc - the object inserted into a cell of a sheet, in a cell is not positioned, the toolbar 'Align' not activated.

I specify a comment_1.
As it seems to me, it is necessary to change the name of control buttons:
1. Toolbar 'Table':
- 'Center_(vertical)' to replace on 'Middle'.
2. Toolbars 'Frame' and 'OLE-object':
- 'Align_left' to replace on 'Left';
- 'Center_Horizontal' to replace on 'Symmetrically';
- 'Align_Right' to replace on 'Right';
- 'Top' to replace on 'Above';
- 'Bottom' to replace on 'Below'.
3. Toolbar 'Align':
- 'Centered' to replace on 'Symmetrically';
- 'Top' to replace on 'Above';
- 'Bottom' to replace on 'Below'.

Created attachment 47293 [details]
Toolbars merged into one picture (EN and RU Languages)

Created attachment 47294 [details]
This summary figure shows should look like "1.png" if my suggestions (Description, Comment_1, Comment_6) will be taken.

Created attachment 47397 [details]
With_Calc_Fjrmating

Oh, I forgot about Calc (Toolbar 'Formating'): with icons - OK, but their names, in my opinion, is necessary for changing.

(In reply to comment #2)
> [Reproducible] with "LibreOffice 3.4.0RC2  – WIN7  Home Premium  (64bit)
> English UI [OOO340m1 (Build:12)]" and TANGO theme. The current icons are
> misleading. 
> 
> Currently I see this as a WRITER UI problem
@Rainer Bielefeld:
Such impression at you could be added because you use the TANGO theme.
It seems to me, I have found the reason which causes this error. The toolbar "Formating\Calc" uses the same icons, as well as toolbars "Frame" and "OLE-object": l{s}c_alignbottom.png; l{s}c_aligntop.png; l{s}c_alignverticalcenter.png; l{s}c_alignleft.png; l{s}c_alignright.png; l{s}c_alignhorizontalcenter.png.
The error will be eliminated in any of three variants.
1. The program code of toolbars "Frame" and "OLE-object" will use toolbar icons "Align":
- "l{s}c_aligndown.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignbottom.png";
- "l{s}c_alignup.png" instead of "l{s}c_aligntop.png";
- "l{s}c_alignmiddle.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignverticalcenter.png";
- "l{s}c_objectalignleft.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignleft.png";
- "l{s}c_objectalignright.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignright.png";
- "l{s}c_aligncenter.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignhorizontalcenter.png".
2. The program code of a toolbar "Formating\Calc" will use icons of toolbars "Formattings\Writer" and "Table\Writer":
- "l{s}c_cellvertbottom.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignbottom.png";
- "l{s}c_cellverttop.png" instead of "l{s}c_aligntop.png";
- "l{s}c_cellvertcenter.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignverticalcenter.png";
- "l{s}c_leftpara.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignleft.png";
- "l{s}c_rightpara.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignright.png";
- "l{s}c_centerpara.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignhorizontalcenter.png";
- "l{s}c_justifypara.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignblock.png".
   Images of toolbars "Frame" and "OLE-object" icons will correspond to images of toolbar "Align" icons:
- "l{s}c_aligndown.png" save as "l{s}c_alignbottom.png";
- "l{s}c_alignup.png" save as "l{s}c_aligntop.png";
- "l{s}c_alignmiddle.png" save as "l{s}c_alignverticalcenter.png";
- "l{s}c_objectalignleft.png" save as "l{s}c_alignleft.png";
- "l{s}c_objectalignright.png" save as "l{s}c_alignright.png";
- "l{s}c_aligncenter.png" save as "l{s}c_alignhorizontalcenter.png".
   The "l{s}c_alignblock.png" icon can be deleted from "images{_all}.zip\res\commandimagelist\.." folders.
3. The program code of toolbars "Frame" and "OLE-object" will use toolbar icons "Align":
- "l{s}c_aligndown.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignbottom.png";
- "l{s}c_alignup.png" instead of "l{s}c_aligntop.png";
- "l{s}c_alignmiddle.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignverticalcenter.png";
- "l{s}c_objectalignleft.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignleft.png";
- "l{s}c_objectalignright.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignright.png";
- "l{s}c_aligncenter.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignhorizontalcenter.png".
   The program code of a toolbar "Formating\Calc" will use icons of toolbars "Formattings\Writer" and "Table\Writer":
- "l{s}c_cellvertbottom.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignbottom.png";
- "l{s}c_cellverttop.png" instead of "l{s}c_aligntop.png";
- "l{s}c_cellvertcenter.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignverticalcenter.png";
- "l{s}c_leftpara.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignleft.png";
- "l{s}c_rightpara.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignright.png";
- "l{s}c_centerpara.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignhorizontalcenter.png";
- "l{s}c_justifypara.png" instead of "l{s}c_alignblock.png".
   "l{s}c_alignblock.png", "l{s}c_alignhorizontalcenter.png", "l{s}c_alignleft.png", "l{s}c_alignright.png", "l{s}c_alignbottom.png" "l{s}c_aligntop.png" and "l{s}c_alignverticalcenter.png" icons can be deleted from "images{_all}.zip\res\commandimagelist\.." folders.

RC2 is bit by bit identical with release version, so separate items in the version picker are useless. Changes have been discussed with Michael Meeks.

for me a buggy behavior is reproducible with LO 4.0.2.2 (Win7 Home, 64bit)

Steps Done:
1. Open with WRITER the attached sample document "sample.odt" from Rainer
2. Click the text frame in the document and assure that the FRAME and ALIGN toolsbar are shown/activated (go to the menu VIEW -> TOOLBARS)
3. Now use the TOP and BOTTOM toolbar icons from the ALIGN and FRAME toolbar

Result: TOP moves the text frame down and BOTTOM moves the text frame up in both toolbars -> this is inconsistent for me


changed the status