Bug 93718

NOTE: I'm actually using the gentoo x11 overlay which seems to be an xorg git...

So reserving movable core on the linux command line seems to cause random failure in my nouveau dual monitor desktop system. (I suspect it's happening to a lessor extent on my radeon laptop as well).

So anyway, I've been using "moveablecore=2G" on my kernel command line for some time in order to accommodate hugepages (etc) for transient virtual machines. When I started playing with SDDM and kde Plasma I started getting display hangs.

The exact moment and error of the hang/error is hard to catch, but just starting sddm is enough to cause my dmesg to fill with faults. They all looked memory/state related so I started playing around.

With no kernelcore= or moveablecore= options on the kernel command line the system seems rock steady.

Using either (they both reserve a movable memory NUMA region that anonymous mappings via mmap() "like" and the kernel is free to relocate by juggling page tables and copying physical images) seems to steal data will-he/nil-he out from under nouveau.

ASIDE: I say it may be happening on my radeon laptop because Chromium gets render-hung there for odd reasons but the diagnostics are more vague.

So the work-around is to not use these options, but I suspect there's some missing page locking or whatever creating phantom failures... particularly in nouveau... particularly under high render pressure.

With "moveablecore=2G kernelcore=3G" I can't even get all the way through the sddm password entry without a messy crash.

This seems to line up with a lot of can-not-duplicate type of error reports I found with google, so I figure'd I drop my datapoint here.